Disingenuous Critical Thinking

Let me start by saying I fully support liberal arts education, and I think discussion of other cultures in a university setting is important. Furthermore, I think our university educational system would be remiss if it did not make students critically consider problems in the world, not just our own country.

These things said, today I found myself in a classroom full of students discussing sex trafficking as it relates to cartels in Mexico. The class consists of privileged (mostly) white young students, myself included. Despite best intentions and usually productive conversation, somehow today we began equating the situation of drug lords and girls kidnapped by the cartels. Suddenly, I was snapped back to the reality that most of these people have no idea what they are talking about and simply want to say something so they get their participation points.

Don’t get me wrong, some comments were genuine–though I consider them misguided nonetheless. The situation of a kidnapped woman forced into sex work and a life she never wanted is not the same as a sicario who decided to join the system instead of fight it. But I digress, my focus in this editorial is misguided critical thinking within college classrooms. We often consider things we have no context for, after all most of us come from white middle-class Midwestern families, so that’s not the problem.

No, the problem is that often we don’t recognize our privilege and lack of knowledge. Then we consider heavy topics and pretend that we are the authorities on the ideas. We ask questions we don’t really care about the answers for. We give answers that are politically correct, and answers that we think others will agree with. No one wants to be wrong. In a different setting, one of the most useful pieces of advice I’ve ever been given is, “Fail is not a bad word. Fail just means you try again.” This is what should be applied to academia, not the mentality that it currently abides.

Isle of Skye

It’s been a few days, sorry! We’ve been busy hiking, exploring and playing on the Isle of Skye. Once again, photos do more justice than my words ever could. I’ll try to caption each picture so you know where we’ve been!

_MG_4659

_MG_4661
The harbor next to our hostel in Portree
_MG_4683
A part of the Cullin Mountains that run through Skye
_MG_4685
Exploring the town
_MG_4700
On the edge of the overlook
_MG_4703
A natural frame

_MG_4716_MG_4717

_MG_4718
Posing for a photo on the edge

_MG_4722

_MG_4726
The edge (in Portree)
_MG_4734
Portree from the Overlook
_MG_4736
Tyler (Portree)
_MG_4740
Mary Jane (Portree)

_MG_4746_MG_4763

_MG_4770
…it me (Portree)
_MG_4776
Sage and her tree (Portree)

_MG_4795

_MG_4797
I like trees okay? (Portree)
_MG_4802
I like walls too. (Portree)
_MG_4806
Golden hour in Portree

_MG_4810

_MG_4817
The overview of the Cullins from Portree

_MG_4824_MG_4839_MG_4849_MG_4856 (2)_MG_4856_MG_4863_MG_4871_MG_4873_MG_4879_MG_4887_MG_4891_MG_4899_MG_4915_MG_4916_MG_4919_MG_4928_MG_4953_MG_4960_MG_4971_MG_4977_MG_4986_MG_4993_MG_4994_MG_4997_MG_5019_MG_5032

Gallery

75 Hours

Today, a photographic representation of the adventures from the past 24 hours. I don’t know how better to describe Loch Ness, hiking through wildlife preserves, and hearing about the rich history of the Highlands than through images.

_MG_4367
View from the Inverness Youth Hostel
_MG_4379
Headed to the city

_MG_4384_MG_4385_MG_4386_MG_4400_MG_4401

_MG_4403
Art from streets

_MG_4414_MG_4422_MG_4426

_MG_4428
Scratched out is “Representing”

_MG_4431

_MG_4445
Crocuses
_MG_4454 (2)
The bell tower at the middle of the city

_MG_4454

_MG_4467
Scared? You wish.

_MG_4479

_MG_4483
Inverness castle

_MG_4497_MG_4512

_MG_4521
A pub with fabulous music
_MG_4522 (2)
The gravestone of Duncan (from MacBeth) behind a convenience store
_MG_4524
Pronounced “Cull-lod-den”

_MG_4526

_MG_4536
About the wall

_MG_4539_MG_4554_MG_4557_MG_4570_MG_4571_MG_4576

_MG_4579
A glamour shot on Loch Ness
_MG_4589
The mists of Loch Ness

_MG_4593_MG_4604_MG_4616

_MG_4649
Red Deer (shot from a moving vehicle)
_MG_4531
A wall representing the deaths at the Battle of Culloden

Tomorrow, on to Portree on the Isle of Skye! Do you believe in fairies?

 

Gallery

50 Hours

First things first. I didn’t post yesterday due to extreme motion sickness. Planes and buses are not my friends, particularly for close to 12 hours as a time. So I apologize for not posting an update on my first day in Scotland, but just know I spent the day mostly sleeping or throwing up. Good times.

Today, on the other hand, was excellent. We wandered about Inverness exploring shops and historical cultural spots. Notable on the list were the Inverness Castle, which sits on hill overlooking the city and now doubles as the courthouse, Leakey’s Bookshop, the largest secondhand bookshop in Scotland, the Inverness Museum and Art Gallery and exploration of the walk around the River Ness.

We started with breakfast at the hostel, then dispersed throughout the city to explore. The walk along the River Ness led us past churches, through florally effervescent streets, and along the road to a few kilt shops/visitor center. The river had some great views of the city, and the aesthetic of the bridges and streets are what can only be described as European.

Inverness Castle, while closed to the public, provided a citywide overlook and some great architectural shots. Shout-out to Tyler for testing his parkour skills, and to the seagull who is completely un-bothered by human interaction.

Leakey’s book store is set up in an old Gaelic church on Church Street in Downtown Inverness. From the old wood burning fireplace to the metal spiral staircase, its a hard-to-beat aesthetic for cozy secondhand book shopping.

Photos will be added later!

 

On International Adventures

Starting Thursday, two days from now, this blog will serve as a journal for my time in Scotland.

Yes, that’s right, I’m going to Scotland! I will be there with one of my best friends, Sage, in a group from Augustana University. We will be exploring the literary tradition and culture of one of the nations that has shaped history on many fronts.

On the long plane ride over, we will be reading The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde and The Crofter and the Laird. While there we will be doing other reading along with exploring various cities. I of course will have my camera and have not yet decided whether to do a visual or literary blog, but only time will tell. Look forward to extremely excited editorials about the landscape and contrasting culture of the UK.

Finally, let me say:

excited1